Scott Walker

this monkey can type!

  • Writing
  • Blog
  • Musings
    • Speaking
    • Articles
    • Interview
    • Presentations
  • About
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Writing / The Writer’s Dilemma: More Money or More Rights?

The Writer’s Dilemma: More Money or More Rights?

Earlier today I tossed out a question to the twitterverse: “Attn writers: Would you prefer to be paid more for your work (and have less rights) or be paid less (and have more rights)?”

My suspicion was that in a digital era where self-publishing is taking an increasingly larger piece of the traditional publishing’s pie, writers are valuing the worth of their intellectual property a bit more than they were twenty years ago. Or, to be more precise, writers have more and easier options to independently extract value from their intellectual property (e.g., online self-publishing).

But, unless you have the means to extract that value on your own (i.e., the time and knowledge to successfully self-publish, which includes marketing, technical, and other considerations), money may still be the priority. Someone’s got to make the cheese sandwiches, right?

Responses on twitter were mixed: @HoppingFun and @vforvoice came down on the rights/it depends side, while @davisac1 and @jchutchins opted for more money.

So, writers, I put it to you: which do you prefer? More money or more rights? More importantly, why or under what conditions?

UPDATE!

I moved some of the twitter responses over here so they wouldn’t be lost. Reviews are mixed, but “depends” seems to be the front runner so far…

@jchutchins: More money, less rights.

@vforvoice: More rights, less money. Media is too expansive to not retain rights for derivatives of original material.

@davisac1: I’d totally sell more rights for more money. That’s what I’d be trying to do with them anyway.

@HoppingFun: Depends on the biz plan and people involved. If I have creative freedom, I’d likely go for a split.

@BFree63: It’s a short term vs long term choice. With more rights comes more money down the road. I call it “investing in yourself”.

@chrisw10: With regards to writing, I think it depends entirely on the long tail. For my 1st story, I want more rights, less money for it, cause I think its too good to let someone tie up rights to it. But for anything I’m doing career-wise, more money, less rights.

[I then asked @chrisw10: “So, career/professional project= money, personal project = rights?”]

@chrisw10: For me, that’s probably how it breaks down. Though any commerical book that I think may be big I’d want to keep e-book rights. Unless giving them up will get me more in the long-run. It’s all about the long run. :)

@JolleySezStuff: Depends — is this a project I’m passionate about? Or did my car just die?

@gmskarka: For most writers, that’s a false dichotomy — More RIghts EQUALS More Money (in the long run).

@floerianthebard: Depends on the piece of work. If I want to do more with it b/c I see potential, I’d take less pay. If it’s a one-off, more pay.

@andrhia: More money, less rights.

@simon_staffans: Best of worlds? More $ first with a buy-back-in-option in the future. Likelihood of happening? Will there ever be world peace?

Filed Under: Writing Tagged With: copyright, digital, intellectual property, publishing

Comments

  1. Guy LeCharles Gonzalez says

    02/25/2011 at 7:02 pm

    I agree with Gareth on the false dichotomy. Transactional writers go for the money first, but career-minded creators focused on the long-game know he owns the rights, wins. Ask any old-school comics creator about that.

    • Scott says

      02/25/2011 at 7:14 pm

      No doubt “both” is better than “one or the other.”

      For me, the question boils down to how best to extract maximum value from an IP. On your own? With a publisher? Some new hybrid model we haven’t seen yet?

      I suspect it also has to do with how many cheese sandwiches a writer requires at the moment.

      And that (ahem) depends on a lot of factors. : )

Trackbacks

  1. Tweets that mention Scott Walker – The Writer’s Dilemma: More Money or More Rights? -- Topsy.com says:
    02/25/2011 at 5:45 pm

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by J.C. Hutchins, Scott Walker, Scott Walker, Scott Walker, Lorraine Hopping and others. Lorraine Hopping said: RT @scott_walker: The Writer's Dilemma: More Money or More Rights? What say, writers? http://bit.ly/e2lH72 #writing […]

  2. The Writer’s Dilemma: More Money or More Rights? | Alexandre Gravel says:
    09/23/2012 at 8:46 am

    […] the worth of their intellectual property a bit more than they were twenty years ago. Or, to …Read the entire article >> Tags: dilemma, money, rights, writers Previous postBourne Legacy: A Spectacular Transmedia […]

This Monkey Can Type

My newsletter for updates, content, and general monkeying around.

Meta Me

Storyteller
Worldbuilder
Creative Catalyst
...and Typing Monkey

Meta Search

Popular Monkey Musings

mathematic formula

Math, Magic, and Storytelling Shell Games

A writer walks into a doctor’s office. “You gotta help me, doc. I keep hearing about everyone making money from self-publishing, and everywhere I go, someone’s trying to sell me their book.” “I see,” the doctor says, nodding. “So what seems to be the problem?” “Well, I figure if everyone’s writing a book, I should […]

Shared Story Worlds

A History and Future of Collaborative Storytelling

This is my (un)scientific, (non-)comprehensive, and (not at all) objective overview of the rise of collaborative storytelling: how we (more or less) got here, and where we may (kinda sorta) be heading. No particular axe to grind or agenda to sell, just my observations after watching this space for a few years. Buckle up, this […]

© 2009 Scott Walker

Privacy

I use cookies to help me create an improved experience for you on this website. If you continue to use this site, you are agreeing to the use of cookies.Ok